How to Run a Sales Contest That Actually Drives Results

Summary:

Forget free pizza. This article offers a blueprint for designing sales incentives that work: tiered rewards, short-term sprints, clear metrics, and gamified dashboards.

Just launched your new business and need resources to ace direct marketing at lower costs with higher ROI?

Check out Salesfully’s course, Mastering Sales Fundamentals for Long-Term Success, designed to help you attract new customers efficiently and affordably.

Explore more free courses

---

Article Begins Below

When it comes to increasing sales performance, few tools work as fast—or flop as hard—as the classic sales contest. Done right, it lights a fire. Done wrong, it's just another “meh” meeting on the calendar.

According to HubSpot, 64% of sales reps say that incentives and rewards are a crucial component of their job satisfaction. Yet, many contests fall flat because they’re either too complicated, reward only top performers, or—worst of all—offer a pizza party as a “prize.”

So how do you craft a sales contest that actually works?

Set Clear, Measurable Goals

The first step is deciding what behavior you want to encourage. Is it call volume? Closed deals? Upselling current clients? Make sure the objective is aligned with overall business goals.

For example, instead of “most sales,” try “most new qualified leads generated” if you’re early in the funnel. Use metrics that are:

• Easy to track

• Directly influenced by reps

• Aligned with long-term success

Use a Tiered Rewards System

Avoid winner-takes-all setups. They alienate everyone who knows they’re not going to beat the office shark.

Instead, try a tiered system:

• Tier 1: Exceeds quota by 20% = $250 bonus

• Tier 2: Hits quota = $100 bonus

• Tier 3: 80–99% of quota = $25 gift card

This gives mid-level performers a reason to keep pushing.

Gamify the Process

People love seeing progress. Use a leaderboard dashboard or internal Slack channel to show results in real-time. Tools like Salesforce, Ambition, or Spiff make it easy to track and visualize sales performance metrics.

Keep It Short and Snappy

Salespeople think in weeks, not quarters. Contests should run for 1–4 weeks max. The urgency keeps energy high and helps new habits stick.

For longer campaigns, break it into weekly sprints with micro-incentives.

Tie It to Follow-Up, Not Just the Close

Don't just reward the close. Focus on the behaviors that lead to revenue—follow-up emails, second calls booked, pipeline creation.

A Harvard Business Review article notes that top-performing sales reps follow up 6–10 times before closing a deal.

Expert Insight: “Contests should reward the controllables—behaviors, not just outcomes. That’s how you build a long-term performance culture,” says Trish Bertuzzi, CEO of The Bridge Group.

Sample Sales Contest Structure

Metric	Goal	Reward	Duration
New Calls Logged	50 per week	$50 gift card	Weekly
Qualified Leads Added	10 per week	Entry into raffle	Weekly
Deals Closed	3 per week	$250 bonus	Monthly

Make the Rewards Meaningful

Cash is nice, but so is a Friday off, a new gadget, or a team dinner. The key is to ask your team what they actually want. A one-question survey goes a long way.

Summary Checklist for Results-Driven Contests

✔ Choose metrics tied to business goals

✔ Keep it simple and transparent

✔ Use tiered rewards

✔ Short time frame = high urgency

✔ Gamify progress

✔ Celebrate publicly

Sales contests don’t have to be cheesy. If designed thoughtfully, they can be a cost-effective way to energize your team, improve habits, and create measurable wins.

Just launched your new business and need resources to ace direct marketing at lower costs with higher ROI?

Check out Salesfully’s course, Mastering Sales Fundamentals for Long-Term Success, designed to help you attract new customers efficiently and affordably.

Don't stop there! Create your free Salesfully account today and gain instant access to premium sales data and essential resources to fuel your startup journey.