The Crowd Has Left the Building

What the Pandemic-Era Venture Crowdfunding Boom Got Right, What It Got Very Wrong, and Where the Money Is Quietly Moving Now

Just launched your new business and need resources to ace direct marketing at lower costs with higher ROI?

Check out Salesfully’s course, Mastering Sales Fundamentals for Long-Term Success, designed to help you attract new customers efficiently and affordably.

Explore more free courses

---

There was a moment during the pandemic when it felt like everyone became a venture capitalist overnight. Locked indoors, stimulus checks burning holes in digital wallets, and a steady drip of “next unicorn” headlines created the perfect conditions for a retail investing gold rush. Venture crowdfunding was no longer a niche curiosity. It was dinner-table conversation, Discord fuel, and Twitter-thread theater.

Platforms like Republic, Wefunder, and even the more consumer-facing Kickstarter rode a wave that blurred the line between belief and due diligence. The pitch decks looked clean. The founders sounded inevitable. And the crowd showed up, wallets open, convinced they were early this time.

When Venture Crowdfunding Worked

To be fair, not all of it was smoke. Some companies used venture crowdfunding exactly as intended. They raised modest but meaningful rounds, validated demand, and turned early backers into genuine brand advocates. Consumer products, climate-adjacent startups, niche fintech tools, and community-driven brands did particularly well.

These were not moonshot valuations. They were businesses that understood cash flow, margins, and patience. In many cases, the crowd replaced what used to be friends-and-family rounds, giving founders breathing room without surrendering control to institutional money too early.

This era proved something important. Retail investors are not inherently reckless. They just respond to incentives and stories the same way professionals do, minus the layers of legal insulation.

Where It Fell Apart

A meaningful slice of pandemic-era venture crowdfunding campaigns were fueled less by fundamentals and more by vibes. Lofty projections. Celebrity advisors who never showed up again. Products still in “concept” mode raising money at prices that assumed flawless execution in a hostile macro environment.

As rates rose and liquidity dried up, the weaknesses became obvious. Follow-on rounds vanished. Secondary liquidity never materialized. Updates slowed, then stopped. Investors learned the hard way that owning private shares is not the same thing as owning stock in public firms.

Many of these failures mirror the same pattern seen in the broader startup ecosystem, well-documented in post-mortems like those highlighted by Crunchbase’s analysis of startup shutdowns. Venture crowdfunding did not invent these problems. It simply made them visible to a wider audience.

The Regulatory Reality Check

Another under-discussed shift has been regulatory fatigue. Equity crowdfunding expanded access, but it also expanded risk exposure for people who were never taught how illiquid private market investing actually is.

The SEC’s investor education resources have become increasingly relevant reading, especially for first-time retail investors navigating Regulation Crowdfunding offerings. This has led platforms to quietly change tone. Less hype. More disclaimers. Smaller rounds. Fewer “revolutionary” claims. That’s not a bug. It’s survival.

What the Future Holds

The next phase looks less like mass speculation and more like targeted participation. Smaller raises. Clearer paths to revenue. Investors who understand they are buying patience, not lottery tickets. The platforms that survive will be the ones that behave less like casinos and more like capital allocators.

Interestingly, this shift mirrors broader conversations happening in alternative investment circles, including those explored on Salesfully’s analysis of private market capital flows, where data-driven decision-making is replacing gut-feel enthusiasm.

Just launched your new business and need resources to ace direct marketing at lower costs with higher ROI?

Check out Salesfully’s course, Mastering Sales Fundamentals for Long-Term Success, designed to help you attract new customers efficiently and affordably.

Don't stop there! Create your free Salesfully account today and gain instant access to premium sales data and essential resources to fuel your startup journey.