Ads in AI Chat: What Happens to Your Marketing When Trust Becomes the Product?

If your pipeline depends on someone else’s algorithm, you don’t have a pipeline. You have a lease.

Just launched your new business and need resources to ace direct marketing at lower costs with higher ROI?

Check out Salesfully’s course, Mastering Sales Fundamentals for Long-Term Success, designed to help you attract new customers efficiently and affordably.

Explore more free courses

---

Somewhere between “AI is magic” and “AI is replacing my job,” we’ve arrived at the newest debate that actually matters to anyone who has to hit a number:

Should AI chat experiences run ads, or should they stay subscription-first?

And before you roll your eyes and say “that’s a product question,” let me save you time: it’s a marketing question. A big one.

Because when the chatbots you use (and the chatbots your customers use) start placing sponsored messages inside answers, trust doesn’t just sit in the background anymore. Trust becomes the product. And the moment trust becomes the product, your customer acquisition strategy needs a Plan B that doesn’t depend on whoever owns the chatbot today.

OpenAI has publicly said it plans to test ads in ChatGPT for some tiers, with guardrails aimed at preserving trust.  And on the other side, Perplexity has pointed to the trust problem as a reason to step away from advertising. That split right there is the whole story.

The real issue: if chatbots become billboards, your funnel gets rented

Most marketers already live with platform risk, even if we don’t call it that.

Platform risk is what happens when your growth depends on rules you don’t control.

One day your ads are printing money, the next day the algorithm changes, attribution breaks, costs spike, and your “predictable pipeline” suddenly needs therapy. The same can happen when AI chat becomes a distribution layer for attention. If the customer journey shifts into AI answers, and those answers include paid placements, then you’re no longer competing only on offer, positioning, and creative.

You’re competing on who can afford the best seat inside the conversation.

So yes, keep experimenting with new channels. But do it like a grown-up with receipts: build an acquisition mix that survives a platform mood swing.

Platform risk, explained like we’re standing by the coffee machine

Here’s the simplest way I can put it:

If one platform can flip a switch and change your results, you don’t have a strategy. You have a dependency.

That dependency shows up in a few ways:

• Your lead gen gets tied to one algorithm

• Your cost per lead rises overnight

• Your reporting turns into modern art

• Your “lead generation tools” work great until they don’t

• Your pipeline becomes sensitive to decisions you didn’t vote on

And if you’re buying “lead generation companies” to patch the leak without fixing the plumbing, you’ll keep paying for the same problem in new packaging.

The antidote is boring, effective, and repeatable: diversify how you create demand, how you capture demand, and how you nurture demand.

A resilient acquisition mix you can control, measure, and repeat

If AI chat ads become normal, the winners won’t be the loudest brands. They’ll be the brands with options.

Here’s a mix that holds up when the internet gets weird:

1) Direct outreach that doesn’t rely on wishful targeting

Direct outreach is still undefeated when done with care. Not spam. Not “just circling back.” Real targeting, real relevance, real follow-up.

This is where your company leads matter. Not random lists. Not scraped chaos. Clean, specific, role-based lists that match your ideal customer profile, so your leads in sales aren’t just names, they’re actual opportunities. If you want to do this the right way, build your prospecting system first, then scale it.

That’s the difference between “lead gen sales” and “I’m busy but broke.”

A solid starting point: build and manage your prospect list with Salesfully so you can generate and track b2b lead generation efforts without duct-taping five tools together.

2) Direct mail (yes, the mailbox) for attention you can actually feel

Digital is crowded. AI chat will be crowded too. Direct mail is what you use when you want a moment of uncluttered attention.

It’s not old-school, it’s underpriced attention.

Use it for:

• warm reactivation (“we haven’t talked in a while”)

• local market penetration

• event-based follow-up

• high-intent offers that deserve a physical touch

Direct mail also plays nicely with first-party data. Someone requests something, you mail it, you follow up, you measure.

3) Partnerships that borrow trust instead of buying it

Partnerships are the quiet engine behind many “overnight successes.” If your audience already trusts someone else, a smart partnership turns that trust into introductions.

Think:

• co-hosted webinars

• newsletter swaps

• referral agreements

• integration partnerships

• community sponsorships

In a world where ads inside AI chat might make people suspicious, partnerships can do the opposite: reduce skepticism.

4) Paid placements, but tested like a scientist, not a gambler

Paid media isn’t the villain. Blind dependency is.

The play is to run paid tests that aren’t tied to one algorithm, one platform, or one mysterious optimization setting that only works on Tuesdays.

If you’re testing B2B placements and want something built for that purpose, use Salesfully B2B Advertising to pressure-test offers and audiences without letting a single platform become your whole identity.

The first-party data play: build a list you own, nurture it weekly

If I had to bet on one thing that will still work no matter what happens with AI chat ads, it’s this:

Own your list. Nurture it weekly. Make it useful.

First-party data is the stuff you collect directly from people who actually want to hear from you: email subscribers, leads who requested a resource, event signups, customers, past customers, product waitlists.

When you own the relationship, you’re not paying rent every time you want to speak.

A simple weekly nurture rhythm:

• one helpful story (what you’re seeing in the market)

• one practical tip (something they can use today)

• one offer (clear next step)

• one CTA that’s consistent for 4–6 weeks (don’t change it every time you get bored)

This is how “sales lead generator” stops being a tool you buy and starts being a system you run. And if you want extra leverage, pair the nurture with practical utilities that bring people back. A good example is offering tools that make their job easier, and collecting opt-ins the right way. You can do that with free marketing tools that support marketing and lead generation while feeding your list with real intent.

So what happens when trust becomes the product?

You adapt like a builder, not like a shopper.

If AI chat goes ad-heavy, you don’t panic. You diversify.

If it stays subscription-first, you still diversify.

Either way, your job is the same: create multiple paths to revenue that you can measure, repeat, and improve.

Because the goal isn’t to “beat the algorithm.”

The goal is to stop needing permission to grow.

Just launched your new business and need resources to ace direct marketing at lower costs with higher ROI?

Check out Salesfully’s course, Mastering Sales Fundamentals for Long-Term Success, designed to help you attract new customers efficiently and affordably.

Don't stop there! Create your free Salesfully account today and gain instant access to premium sales data and essential resources to fuel your startup journey.